MCKEEN’S 2026 NHL PROSPECT REPORT – #19 Columbus Blue Jackets – Organization Overview – Top 15 Prospects

 

Prospect System Ranking – 19th (Last Year - 19th)
GM: Don Waddell Hired: May 2024
COACH: Rick Bowness Hired: January 2025

Despite missing the playoffs, the Columbus Blue Jackets are beginning to show signs of progress. A growing group of young NHL contributors has started to hit its stride, with players such as Adam Fantilli and Kirill Marchenko emerging as key offensive drivers. Meanwhile, Kent Johnson, Denton Mateychuk, Cole Sillinger, Luca Pinneli (188th) and Luca Del Bel Belluz (94th) continue to develop into important complementary pieces of the roster. Slowly but surely, Columbus is assembling a more competitive and well-rounded lineup. The organization also signalled its intent to accelerate that progress during the 2025–26 season, acquiring veteran forwards Mason Marchment and Conor Garland. Those additions suggest the Blue Jackets are ready to move beyond the rebuilding phase and begin pushing toward meaningful contention.

Behind the NHL roster, the prospect system continues to develop across multiple leagues. A significant portion of the organization’s high-end talent is currently playing in the NCAA, with several top prospects gaining valuable collegiate experience. Defenseman Jackson Smith, ranked 30th in McKeen’s prospect rankings, has enjoyed an impressive freshman season at Penn State and currently sits among the top-producing defenders in the NCAA. Forward Cayden Lindstrom (52nd), meanwhile, is healthy and progressing through his freshman campaign after injury concerns. William Whitelaw has emerged as a breakout performer at Western Michigan, producing at nearly a point-per-game pace. In Russia, the Blue Jackets also have promising depth in goal. Sergei Ivanov, 21, has spent most of his time at the KHL level, posting an impressive .928 save percentage with three shutouts. Meanwhile, 2025 first-round selection Pyotr Andreyanov (75th) has split his season between the VHL and MHL, with most of his success coming at the junior level.

Another encouraging sign for Columbus is its intact draft capital. The organization has managed to maintain selections in every round of the 2026 NHL Draft, providing additional opportunities to strengthen the system. Regardless of how the current season ultimately unfolds, the Blue Jackets appear to be trending in a positive direction both at the NHL level and throughout their prospect pipeline.

1. Jackson Smith, D, Penn State University (NCAA)

   The standout Penn State defenseman joined the team this year after being selected fourteenth overall by the Blue Jackets in the summer of 2025. Smith brings not only a decent size to the blue line, standing at 6’4”, but also some high end skating combined with great stickhandling skills and creativity. It showed in his point production, where he finished the NCAA season with 26 points in 35 games, tops among defenseman on the team. The freshman did not look out of place playing collegiate hockey and transitioned easily into his role as an offensive threat for the Nittany Lions. The one aspect of Smith’s game that stands out right away is his elite skating for his size. From his separation speed, to his four-way mobility and easy transitions, it is no wonder he was highly sought after during the NHL draft. You combine that with his puck control skills and high end shot, Smith will always be a high-end offensive threat every time he steps on the ice. And the defensive part of his game has also been evolving, making him a dual threat from the backend. The Blue Jackets will be very happy once Smith joins the club full time down the road.

2. Cayden Lindstrom, C, Michigan State University (NCAA)

   After missing a good amount of time during the past two seasons owing to injury, Lindstrom finally made his hockey debut for the Spartans this year and took a little time to get the cobwebs loose and adjust to the speed of college hockey. He responded with a decent freshman outing, putting up 10 points in 31 games. Now the numbers don’t tell the full story, as Lindstrom plays a power forward style game and he is best suited for those battles along the boards and in front of the net. He seemed to embrace his role for Michigan State and helped them become one of the best, if not the best, team in the NCAA. Lindstrom provides some added toughness and grit to the Blue Jackets pipeline and will most likely wreak havoc to opposing teams once he makes the jump to the big club. There may still be some time spent in the NCAA for him to develop and return to top form, but the reward will be worth the wait. The big power forward will also need to get his offensive mojo back if he wants to make an impact at the NHL level. His struggles on the scoresheet this season are hopefully just a one-off and expect him to increase on those totals next year. Columbus is surely hoping Lindstrom can develop into a reliable NHL power forward for their team at some point.

3. Pyotr Andreyanov, G, Zvezda Moscow (VHL)

   Andreyanov has taken a slight step back this season after his outstanding campaign last year. He started the year in the VHL, but his subpar play got him demoted back to the MHL, where his GAA has taken a significant hit. He is still the uber athletic, explosive and dexterous goalie that Columbus picked at 20 last draft, making difficult plays look easy and producing highlight reel saves when necessary. His ability to anticipate play and track pucks through traffic is excellent as well, adding to his impressive toolkit. The weaknesses in his game come from poor angles when he is forced to move laterally across his crease. He leaves the short side open and has had issues with stopping low glove shots in those situations. He is also slightly on the heavier side. If he can shed some weight while adding muscle, the athleticism could be otherworldly as he is already very gifted. Some slight tweaks to his positioning and techniques could turn him into a star, and he has plenty of time in an excellent goalie developmental system with Krasnaya to get him there.

4. Luca Del Bel Belluz, C, Cleveland Monsters (AHL)

   For Del Bel Belluz, it’s all about finding a way to breakthrough offensively at the NHL level. He has proven that he can be an impact offensive player at the AHL level with Cleveland. However, that same consistency has not yet carried over to the NHL level. He had a strong cup of coffee last year with the Jackets, but this year’s run was significantly less effective. As he inches closer to the end of his waiver exemption, he will need to prove to Columbus that he can be a top nine player for them. The skill and touch are there. Del Bel Belluz is a skilled play creator who protects the puck well and operates with a quick strike mentality. However, he needs to find a way to discover more success playing through the middle and in higher traffic areas at the NHL level to take that next step. The Jackets have three key top nine forwards entering this offseason as UFA’s and that could create room for LDBB to finally breakthrough next year. He still has terrific upside to be an offensive contributor, even if some tweener concerns are creeping in.

5. Luca Marrelli, D, Cleveland Monsters (AHL)

   Offseason shoulder surgery delayed Marelli’s pro debut until only recently, but the former Oshawa General standout has been quick to make an impact with the Cleveland Monsters.
   Marrelli’s best asset is unquestionably his brain; he’s an extremely intelligent defender. Marrelli rarely turns the puck over and is calm under pressure, making him a high-end facilitator and powerplay quarterback. He’s not a physical player, but he is effective in the defensive end too, because of his good four-way mobility and defensive instincts. While the Jackets will likely take his development slow the rest of the season given his injury recovery, he has the potential to move quickly through the organization and into a main club role. It’s not inconceivable to see him up with the Jackets full time next year in a third pairing role. He projects as a serviceable two-way second pairing type who can operate as a Swiss Army knife, plying his trade on both special team’s units.

6. Luca Pinelli, C, Cleveland Monsters (AHL)

   Given his lack of size and elite physical tools, there was some concern over the translatability of Pinelli’s skill set to the pro game. He had improved over four years with the Ottawa 67’s, but concerns lingered. However, his first pro season has been solid so far, with Pinelli even earning a cup of coffee with the Jackets as an injury fill in. He’s such a competitive player; he never stops moving his feet and he’s always in attack mode. That gives him an advantage and allows him to overcome a lack of size/speed. Pinelli is also a skilled playmaker who protects the puck well through traffic despite his smaller stature. Not likely to become a premier offensive player at the NHL level, Pinelli should be able to carve out a long career playing through the middle of a lineup. Given the aforementioned Jackets’ forwards who are UFA’s, Pinelli might have the opportunity to secure a bottom six spot next season with a good offseason and training camp. Danton Heinen’s replacement perhaps?

7. Jordan Dumais, RW, Cleveland Monsters (AHL)

   Injuries have not been kind to Dumais the last few seasons. The former QMJHL scoring star had struggled to stay on the ice for the last few years, missing time due to hernia surgery, upper body injuries, and hip issues. However, he’s been healthy this year and that’s the main positive as he tries to find his footing at the pro level. The Blue Jackets are going to have to be patient with his development given all the time missed. So, while his production this year with the Monsters has been somewhat disappointing, it’s important to remember the context. An extremely skilled and intelligent offensive player, Dumais’ ceiling is extremely high. However, his lack of size and dynamic skating ability has always brought forward questions regarding the probability of his NHL success. It’s still too early to come to any concrete conclusions; Dumais remains a high upside player. Next season will be the big one for him as he will need to prove that he can be an offensive leader at the AHL level first.

8. William Whitelaw, RW, Western Michigan University (NCAA)

   The 33rd overall selection of the Blue Jackets in the 2023 NHL draft, joined Western Michigan after two seasons in the NCAA on different teams, and his involvement with the reigning collegiate champs has been nothing but remarkable. Whitelaw popped off offensively this year, posting an impressive 34 points in 39 games, good enough for third on the team in scoring. His ability to help out on the scoresheet is a testament to his development and WMU’s trust in his overall game. The third-year player has elite speed and can easily navigate through the toughest tight areas, owing to his high level four-way mobility and balance. Whitelaw also possesses some great scoring skills and racked up 19 goals for the Broncos, which was second best on the team. He is a gritty player for his size, listed at 5-foot-9 and not afraid to battle down low or along the wall. The question is, will all of these attributes translate into an NHL career? Only time will tell, but Whitelaw’s development curve so far has been positive, and he could one day push for a Blue Jackets roster spot.

9. Sergei Ivanov, G, St. Petersburg (KHL)

   Ivanov has had an up and down career in the Russian pro leagues. After loans to Sochi and Vladivostok, he has returned to St.Petersburg and is playing well. He is on pace to have his best record and the GAA and SV% has come back to par. He makes up for his smaller size with high-end athleticism and quick lateral mobility. Strong going post to post and covers the bottom of his net well by utilizing the butterfly and his ability to adjust in tight. He is still struggling to fight through screens and has a tendency to lose pucks in scrums, scrambling to follow the play. His ability to read the game is inconsistent but his aggressive nature and strong pushoffs help make up for his poor positioning. There is a tendency to overcommit though, skating himself out of his crease and leaving backdoor passes or rebounds wide open. There is a strong base here and a move to North America to work on his technical play and tightening up his positioning could see him making the NHL one day.

10. Evan Gardner, G, Saskatoon Blades (WHL)

    By this point it's fair to say that things haven't quite gone as expected for Gardner or the Blue Jackets since the goaltender was selected by Columbus 60th overall in 2024. The Blades were a stalwart defensive club that season and that might have painted a misleading picture of their then-rookie netminder, particularly through his sky-high save percentage, which has been free-falling ever since. His performances in the playoffs have also lagged behind his regular season results, which is another bad sign. There aren't any specific or serious concerns about his game, necessarily. He's about as balanced and well-rounded as goalies his age come. But rather, the problem is that nothing about him truly stands out. His technique, reflexes, puck tracking, rebound control and mental acuity are all more good than they are great, and that's not an ideal makeup for a goalie who doesn't have an abundance of natural size to fall back on. Gardner has already signed his entry-level contract, so Columbus will try to develop him as much as possible in the coming years.

11. Charlie Elick, D, Tri-City Americans (WHL)

    At this point, you have to operate under the assumption that the offensive game will never really be a strength. However, his size, mobility, and physicality do make him a potentially elite shutdown defender, which is why he was an early second round selection.

12. Guillaume Richard, D, Cleveland Monsters (AHL)

    Richard is a lot like Elick, but perhaps with a little less upside because his physical tools are not as elite. He’s already proven to be a strong defensive presence in the AHL as a rookie and he is tracking towards being a quality third pairing type for the Jackets.

13. Oiva Keskinen, C, Tappara (Liiga)

    Keskinen is looking like a solid pick by the Jackets when they took him as an overager late in 2023. He’s improved every year in Liiga and has emerged as one of the top young forwards in Finland.

14. Jack Williams, RW, Cleveland Monsters (AHL)

    The former Northeastern star was signed as a free agent by the Jackets last year and his first year in the AHL has been largely solid. He’s been one of the Monsters’ top offensive performers and has been solid away from the puck too.

15. Corson Ceulemans, D, Cleveland Monsters (AHL)

    Columbus has been very patient with their 2021 first round pick out of the AJHL. Since leaving Wisconsin Ceulemans has struggled to be a fairly impactful defender at the pro level, but he’s having his best season to date at both ends, providing some hope that he can at least be a solid depth defender in the near future.